ABOUT THIS RECIPEA tart in two layers
Torta della nonna is a well-known Tuscan tart: shortcrust pastry encases a pastry cream filling, topped with pine nuts. The combination is simple, but it depends on contrast. The pastry should be crisp and golden, while the cream stays soft and holds its shape when sliced. Lemon zest gives the custard a fresh aroma that balances the rich flavors of butter, milk and egg yolk. The pine nuts toast as the tart bakes, adding a subtle, nutty bite on top.
Good custard starts with even cooking. Heat the milk with lemon zest and mix the egg yolks with sugar and cornstarch before pouring in the warm milk. Adding the milk gradually warms the yolks gently. Back in the pan, the cream thickens further; keep stirring and scrape along the bottom and corners too, where it can catch first. Then let the cream cool completely. A warm filling would soften the butter in the pastry and make the tart harder to handle.
Cold pastry is just as important here. Keeping the butter firm at first helps the dough hold its shape better as you roll it out, giving it a crumbly, crisp texture after baking. If the dough gets sticky or tears as you line the tin, chill it briefly again instead of adding extra flour; too much flour makes the crust dry. A loose-bottomed tart tin with a diameter of 24 centimeters works well. Don’t prick the base: the cream needs to stay inside the pastry.
Cornstarch makes a smooth, fairly light cream and thickens quickly. You can replace it with flour, but the custard will be a little firmer and should simmer gently for a few more minutes after thickening to cook out the floury taste. Pine nuts are characteristic of this tart; flaked almonds can be used as an alternative, but they give it a distinctly different flavor and texture. Lemons are generally available even outside their season, so the tart doesn’t depend on a short harvest period.
Let the baked tart cool completely before slicing: the custard continues to set as it cools. You can dust it lightly with powdered sugar just before serving, but it isn’t necessary. Serve the tart for dessert after a meal or with coffee. Store leftovers covered in the refrigerator and eat them within three days; let a slice sit at room temperature briefly before serving so the pastry and cream aren’t ice-cold.