ABOUT THIS RECIPECrispy, Creamy and Fresh
Potatoes and chickpeas make this dish hearty enough for a main meal, but they’re prepared in different ways. First, boil the small potatoes until tender, then crush them so the surface breaks open. Those rough edges brown especially well in the oven and turn crispy, while the centers stay soft. Chickpeas, on the other hand, benefit from a dry start: dry them thoroughly after rinsing and give them plenty of room on the baking sheet. That way, they roast instead of steam.
Cumin gives the chickpeas a warm, earthy flavor, while smoked paprika adds a mild smokiness. The spices are noticeable, but not so strong that they overpower the green sauce. Add them while the chickpeas roast, rather than to the potatoes early on: this keeps the potato flavor bright and prevents the paprika from getting too dark. If everything won’t fit with plenty of space between the ingredients, use two baking sheets; crowded ingredients won’t get as crispy.
Parsley, lemon and yogurt bring freshness and acidity to balance the roasted flavors. Stir the sauce by hand for a chunky, herby texture, or blend it briefly until smooth if you prefer a more even consistency. Greek yogurt makes a thicker sauce; regular full-fat yogurt will make it a little looser. Adjust the consistency with a spoonful of water. No fresh parsley on hand? You can use a combination of parsley and mint, but go easy on the mint so it doesn’t take over.
The fennel is added raw and thinly shaved. It brings fresh, juicy crunch alongside the soft potato centers and creamy sauce. A mandoline is handy, but a sharp knife works just fine; slice the fennel as thinly as possible. Fennel is especially easy to find in the cooler months, but is generally available year-round. Serve the dish straight from the oven, with the sauce on top or on the side so the crispy edges don’t soften right away. Store leftovers covered in the fridge and reheat them in the oven; the fennel and sauce are best fresh.