ABOUT THIS RECIPEBitter, tart and crunchy in one spoonful
This custard is all about contrast. Dark chocolate gives it a deep, bittersweet base, while sour cherries add juiciness and a bright, fruity flavor. Rye bread brings a toasted, savory note. Every spoonful has a different texture: silky custard, soft fruit and crumbs that stay crunchy until just before serving.
The custard thickens thanks to egg yolks, not flour or cornstarch. Warm the mixture gently and keep stirring, especially along the bottom and into the corners of the pan. Once the custard coats the back of a spoon, it’s thick enough; don’t let it boil, or the yolks may curdle. A thermometer is useful: aim for about 82–84 °C. The chocolate makes the chilled custard firmer, so don’t expect it to be as thick as a pudding while warm.
Choose a dark chocolate you enjoy eating, preferably around 65–70 percent cacao. A higher cacao percentage makes the custard more intense and less sweet; taste the milk mixture before adding the chocolate and adjust the sugar slightly if needed. Sour cherries from a jar or can work year-round. Drain them well, but save a little juice to serve with the fruit. Fresh sour cherries are a lovely alternative in summer; sweet cherries work too, but give less of that bright contrast.
Firm rye bread works best for the crumble. Break it into coarse crumbs and fry them in a skillet with butter until dry and crunchy. A little sugar caramelizes as it cooks and rounds out the bread’s slightly bitter flavor. Avoid sweet rye bread if you can: the topping should taste savory and toasted. If you don’t have rye bread, you can use whole wheat bread, though the result will be milder.
Divide the custard among small dishes and give it at least four hours to chill and set. Cover and refrigerate it; keep the cherries and crumble separate and add them at the table. That way, the topping stays crunchy. This dessert goes well after a meal with pronounced savory flavors, and small portions are plenty because of the rich chocolate base.